The First Commandment?

In page 40 you quote the First Commandment from a Jewish text. Are you Jewish?

Joseph

I am not Jewish, but at the age of 7 I was thrown out of catholic katechism class in Poland for asking too many questions.

The First Commandment was first recorded by Moses, who wrote it down in Hebrew together with the other nine, in the second of his books, called Exodus. The five books of Moses are the basis of the so-called Old Testament.

Hence, the First Commandment is the foundation of both Judaism and Christianity.

In my meditations, followed by studies of original texts, I found, that the First Commandment (Exodus 20:3) recorded by Moses in Hebrew is mis-translated and hence mis-interpreted in all languages on Earth.

Traditional translation (for example Aryeh Kaplan [4]) is as follows:
(20:3) "Do not have any gods before Me. Do not represent (such gods) by any carved statue or picture or anything in the heaven above or the earth below or in the water below the land. Do not bow down to or worship them."

My translation is this:
(20:3) Do not have any gods before Me. Do not represent (me) by any carved statue or picture or anything in the heaven above or the earth below or in the water below the land. Do not bow down to or worship them."

In traditional (Kaplan [4]) translation, the second sentence (such gods) contradicts the intention of the first. If all other gods are forbidden to begin with, WHY devote the next sentence to them? Also, the singular (statue or picture) in the second sentence contradicts plural "gods" in the first. This indicates, that the second sentence refers to the singular object mentioned in the first sentence. The ONLY singular object there that qualifies is God itself.

My translation is explicitly re-confirmed later in (20:20): "Do not make a representation of anything that is with Me". Such an explicit and precise repeat re-confirms the importance of this advice. Note, that no other commandment is re-confirmed that way.

Honestly translated First Commandment, reinforced by (20:20), explicitly and specifically forbids people creating any religion, any altar, any church and any clergy whatsoever, simply because all of these things fundamentally mis-represent Creator, who does NOT need a proxy of any kind. Could this fundamental conflict with clergy be a reason why Moses was eliminated and his body never found?

Perverted First Commandment is a source of untold human misery for thousands of years, conflicts, wars, all based on doctrines that explicitly contradict it. We have eyes, but do we see?

If you have The Freedom book edition with perverted (traditional) translation, please ammend it as above. Current pdf contains this correction.

Tom

My interpretation is - God does not have a form and no one should represent him in any form for worship. God is all.

Justine

Whoever says that "God is all" doesn't even begin to suspect who God is and how to find God. Do you remember WHO told you this nonsense? Please examine their MOTIVES.

If you need more explanation, search for God at this Forum.

Tom